was this wrong

[GotaFancy?]

You also have to give some consideration to the poster and their track record - that's why Nade would get a slating where Davey didn't

[Nade]

It's a wonder i'm still here.

[goater14(BPP)]

Originally Posted by Fonzie14

I think it aws the pre-flop call that Davey was getting slated for (which with 7:1 odds to see a flop I can't fault). He was first to push post flop, which I totaly agree with.

If I remember rightly it was 'ImMrMuscle' who was mouthing off, and if its any consolation he went out in 12th place and winged on for about 10 mins afterwards.

LoL ImMrMuscle Im not the only one who got a mouthful of him then.

[WASP]

Originally Posted by slapdash

I think that's a little unfair in this case. I'd agree if it were an "I called his all-in with the nuts and he hit a runner-runner straight to knock me out. Should I have played it differently?" kind of post, which has no genuine strategy point. But here there was a legitimate question about the play.

I'd have preferred not to be given the outcome of the hand to begin with, though: just the situation when you have to decide what to do preflop.

I agree